Kalinski1970's Blog

My own personal view on UK Education and bits n bobs

.@Geoffbastin @Bayliss4BB @jpkemp94 @Jolph @HuwMerriman what are your views on plans for new grammar schools? #compfuture

2 Comments

Earlier I followed a link from @comp_future, which can be found here, http://act.comprehensivefuture.org.uk/campaigns/nonewgrammarschools, and decided to adjust it from an East Sussex perspective.  I would like to thank Hugh Hennebry for the paragraphs quoted.

Please accept my apologies for emailing you all together.

As a headteacher in East Sussex I wanted to raise the issues I have with this possible policy. We should not expand selective education. The many education experts who have criticized this proposal should be listened to. We need well funded schools and a commitment to high quality comprehensive education.

These are some of the problems with selective education:

– Grammar schools contain mostly pupils from wealthy backgrounds with low numbers of pupils from poorer backgrounds. The education of disadvantaged and SEN pupils should be our priority.

– There are three secondary modern schools created for each grammar school. Secondary modern schools are less likely to have top sets and a range of A levels, and they often find it harder to recruit teachers. We should offer high quality all-ability schools to all pupils.

– Grammar schools involve competition for school places which leads parents to waste money on expensive 11-plus tutoring. We should not expand the £25 million a year 11-plus tuition industry.

– The 11-plus test sends a discouraging message to children at the start of secondary school. We should not base school admission on a damaging test that suggests ‘innate ability’ is definable and matters more than hard work.

Finally, our sitting MP has already stated that he doesn’t see this as a funding issue, but

“the capital funding does affect our schools. There are many of our schools that are unfit for purpose. How many schools are riddled with asbestos, crittal windows, poor insulation, 1950s electrics (our main fuse was put in at the time Winston Churchill was Prime Minister and it is still there), iron pipes that rust as they lie under reinforced concrete slabs, flat rooves covered in bitumen / felt (this isn’t great for a domestic garage let alone a school for thousands of people) etc?

If they divert capital funds to enlarge grammar schools, it will take away money from much needed investment in world class education facilities and the sort of teaching and learning environment the children of Britain deserve.”
Comprehensive education works, especially here in East Sussex, where the schools serve the broad social mix of our communities fantastically well. One grammar school in any of the market towns would instantly turn all three others into secondary moderns. The most successful nations use all ability secondary schools, and areas that operate selective education show poor results, with worrying outcomes for disadvantaged pupils.

I hope that you will oppose new grammar schools and protect comprehensive education. 

Kind regards

Advertisements

Author: kalinski1970

Headteacher at a school in rural East Sussex! Trust me the problems are real and difficult. Married to an amazing woman with two wonderful children (sometimes...)

2 thoughts on “.@Geoffbastin @Bayliss4BB @jpkemp94 @Jolph @HuwMerriman what are your views on plans for new grammar schools? #compfuture

  1. I really like this – the sort of clear messaging that we need. I’m inclined to think that anti-grammar campaigners spend too long arguing about FSM percentages and the like when that is not really what matters to most parents. Is it possible for the geniuses who produced the School Cuts website to do some statistical wizardry showing what might happen to comprehensives which become secondary moderns – by for instance comparing results in Kent to a similar county?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s